Welding Processes

Methods of Welding Cast Iron and High-Carbon Steel

Methods for welding cast iron and higher-carbon steels: filler and rod choices, preheat, peening and slow cooling, plus joining 1045 to 1018 steel.

On this page
  1. Why cast iron is hard to weld
  2. Identify what you have
  3. Methods and filler choices
  4. Step-by-step repair
  5. Which welder is best
  6. Welding medium-carbon to low-carbon steel (1045 to 1018)
  7. Related questions

Why cast iron is hard to weld

Cast iron contains a lot more carbon than structural steel, typically above 2%, much of it as graphite flakes or nodules. When a weld cools quickly, the area next to it can form hard, brittle microstructure that cracks easily. The casting is also often thick and uneven, which causes large temperature differences and stress as it heats and cools. Most advice for welding cast iron is about managing those two problems: carbon and thermal stress.

Higher-carbon steels share part of this issue. The more carbon (and alloying) a steel has, the faster it hardens near the weld and the more care is needed with preheat and cooling.

Identify what you have

Many failed repairs begin with a wrong identification.

  • Gray cast iron is the most common (engine blocks, manifolds, vises, old machinery). It is brittle and breaks without bending.
  • Ductile (nodular) iron and malleable iron are more forgiving but still need procedure.
  • Cast steel looks like cast iron but welds much more like steel.
  • Aged or oil-soaked castings can be contaminated and may not weld well.

A spark test, markings, the part’s age and function, and how it broke all help. If you can’t tell, test on a scrap area first.

Methods and filler choices

Nickel-based stick electrodes. Nickel (often 99% nickel) and nickel-iron (about 55% nickel) electrodes are the common choice. The deposit stays relatively soft and ductile and tolerates the carbon that mixes in from the base metal. Opinions differ about which is better in a given case. Nickel-iron is often chosen for strength and cost, and pure nickel for easier machining.

Braze welding. A bronze-type filler is melted at a lower temperature than the iron’s melting point, so the base iron doesn’t melt. This reduces stress, though the joint is only as strong as the filler and bond, and it isn’t suited to high-temperature service.

Preheated welding with ferrous filler. For some castings, the entire part is heated evenly to a high temperature, welded, then cooled very slowly. It is effective but takes equipment, skill and time, and the part must be small enough to heat evenly.

Mild steel filler. Generally avoided because carbon from the base iron makes the deposit hard and brittle. Specialist procedures exist but aren’t a beginner’s route.

Step-by-step repair

  1. Clean the area. Remove paint, rust, oil and scale. Cast iron can absorb oil, so grinding down to clean metal, and sometimes heating to drive out contamination, helps.
  2. Stop the crack. Drill a small hole just beyond each end of a crack so it won’t continue to spread.
  3. Groove the crack. Grind a V or U groove along the crack, usually most of the way through the thickness, to give the weld a good base.
  4. Preheat as required. The amount depends on the filler and the casting. Nickel electrodes are often used with low preheat or none, keeping the casting only warm. Ferrous-filler methods call for much higher preheat. Follow the electrode maker’s guidance.
  5. Weld in short beads. Many guides suggest stitches of roughly an inch or less, at low amperage, letting the part cool a little between beads so the heat doesn’t build up.
  6. Peen each bead. While the weld is still hot, lightly tap it with a peening hammer. This stretches the weld and relieves shrinkage stress.
  7. Cool slowly. Cover the part with a welding blanket, dry sand or similar, and keep it out of drafts.

Which welder is best

Stick welding with nickel-based electrodes is the most common choice for hobby and repair work because the equipment is simple and portable. Oxy-fuel is used for braze welding and for preheating. MIG and TIG with specialty nickel wire or rod are used in some shops. For an overview of how these compare, see welding processes and equipment.

Welding medium-carbon to low-carbon steel (1045 to 1018)

AISI 1018 is a low-carbon steel (about 0.18% carbon) and is generally considered easy to weld. 1045 is a medium-carbon steel (about 0.45% carbon), and it is more prone to hardening and cracking near the weld. Joining the two is routine, but the 1045 side drives the procedure:

  • Use a low-hydrogen filler such as E7018 stick or an ER70S-type solid MIG or TIG wire, a common choice for carbon steels.
  • Clean the joint well; see preparing metal for welding.
  • Preheat the 1045 side moderately, especially on thicker sections, to slow cooling. Exact temperatures depend on thickness and the procedure.
  • Avoid rapid cooling, and consider slow cooling or post-weld heat treatment on important parts.
  • If the part will be hardened or heat treated afterward, plan the sequence before welding.

Heavily stressed shafts or safety-critical parts should follow an engineered procedure.

Can you weld cast steel with 7018? Cast steel is steel, so it is commonly welded with low-hydrogen electrodes such as E7018, with preheat appropriate to its composition. This is different from cast iron, where 7018 is generally not recommended.

Can 1018 steel be welded? Yes, readily, with stick, MIG, TIG or oxy-fuel.

Can I weld mild steel with argon? Argon on its own is typically used for TIG. For MIG on mild steel, an argon and carbon dioxide mix or straight CO2 is more common, since pure argon tends to give poor arc stability and penetration on steel. See TIG vs MIG.

How do you weld steel with oxy-acetylene? A neutral flame melts the edges of a clean joint and filler rod is added to the puddle. It’s suited to thin material and repairs; the process takes practice in controlling the flame and puddle.

What is the thinnest metal that can be welded? There’s no single limit. Very thin sheet can be welded with TIG, with low-current MIG, or with resistance welding. Thinner metal needs more control to avoid burn-through, and technique matters as much as equipment.

The complete guide to welding processes

Welding Processes and Equipment: A Beginner's Guide
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →