Gas and Forge Welding

Oxy-Acetylene Flame Types: Neutral, Carburizing and Oxidizing

What neutral, carburizing and oxidizing oxy-acetylene flames look and sound like, how to adjust each one, and which metals and jobs they suit.

On this page
  1. The three flames at a glance
  2. How to set each one
  3. Neutral
  4. Carburizing
  5. Oxidizing
  6. Which metal gets which flame
  7. Common problems

The three flames at a glance

The three flame types differ in the ratio of oxygen to acetylene reaching the tip.

Flame Gas ratio What you see Sound
Carburizing (reducing) Excess acetylene A bright inner cone with a whitish “feather” of acetylene around it Soft
Neutral Roughly equal oxygen and acetylene A sharply defined, rounded inner cone with no feather Steady, soft hiss
Oxidizing Excess oxygen A shorter, pointed inner cone, often with a purple tinge Harsh, louder hiss

How to set each one

Start with the torch lit on acetylene alone, which gives a yellow, smoky flame. Then:

  1. Increase the acetylene until the smoke stops and the flame just leaves the tip.
  2. Add oxygen slowly. The flame forms a bright inner cone, and the acetylene feather around it shrinks.
  3. When the feather is just gone and the cone is clearly defined, you have a neutral flame.
  4. To make it carburizing, back the oxygen off until a feather reappears. To make it oxidizing, add oxygen until the inner cone shortens and the sound sharpens.

Adjust at the torch valves. For lighting steps, see how to set up and light an oxy-acetylene torch.

Neutral

The neutral flame is the default for welding most steels. It is commonly quoted at around 3,000°C (about 5,400°F), hottest just past the tip of the inner cone. It neither adds carbon to nor removes it from the molten metal in any significant way, and it produces a clean puddle.

Keep the tip of the inner cone a short distance from the work, not touching it. Check the flame occasionally, because it drifts as the tip heats up or the regulators change slightly.

Carburizing

A carburizing flame has too much acetylene. The extra fuel can add carbon to the molten steel, which tends to make the weld harder and more brittle if overdone. A slightly carburizing flame is used in some cases, for example:

  • Some hard-facing work.
  • Aluminium and some non-ferrous jobs, where a slightly reduced flame limits oxidation.
  • Pre-heating and soft brazing situations, where a lower-temperature, softer flame is wanted.
  • Adjusting up to a neutral flame, since it is easy to spot the feather.

It is a cooler flame than neutral, but the sooty acetylene can leave carbon deposits.

Oxidizing

An oxidizing flame has excess oxygen. It burns hotter than neutral, and it can oxidize the molten metal, leaving a porous, weak weld with a lot of sparks and a rough puddle. For most steel welding it is a fault to avoid.

It is deliberately used for some work. Bronze welding often uses a slightly oxidizing flame to help the filler flow and to limit zinc fuming, and some brass work uses it for similar reasons. See torch brazing and bronze welding for more.

Which metal gets which flame

These are general rules of thumb. Check the filler rod maker’s recommendation for your job.

  • Mild and low-alloy steel: neutral.
  • Cast iron: neutral, or slightly carburizing in some procedures; see methods of welding cast iron.
  • Brass and bronze (welding or bronze welding): slightly oxidizing.
  • Copper: neutral, with plenty of heat input because copper conducts heat away quickly.
  • Aluminium: neutral to slightly carburizing, with flux. It is a difficult material for gas welding. For other options, see the best way to repair aluminum.

Common problems

  • Popping or backfiring at the tip. Often caused by a dirty or overheated tip, working too close to the work, or wrong pressures. Shut the torch off, let it cool and check the tip.
  • Flame keeps drifting. Check the regulators, hoses and cylinder level.
  • Soot on the work. Too much acetylene.
  • Sparks and a rough, boiling puddle. Often too much oxygen.

Selecting a suitable tip also affects the flame; see choosing the right oxy-acetylene tip size. For the bigger picture, our gas welding overview explains how the flame fits into the process.

The complete guide to gas and forge welding

Gas Welding: How Oxy-Acetylene Welding Works
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →