Short answer
Most steels forge weld at a bright yellow to yellow-white heat, which is commonly quoted as roughly 2,100°F to 2,300°F (about 1,150°C to 1,260°C). The exact figure depends on the steel, and no single number is right for every grade, so most smiths rely on colour and surface appearance rather than a thermometer.
Ranges by steel type
These are rough, commonly cited ranges, not specifications:
- Mild steel and wrought iron tolerate, and often need, the highest heat. Some smiths weld them at the upper end of the range or slightly above, until the surface looks glossy or “sweaty”.
- Medium- and high-carbon steels are usually welded nearer the lower end, because they are more prone to burning and grain growth if overheated. Many smiths who work with 1095 or similar steels aim around 2,000°F to 2,200°F.
- Alloy steels vary with their composition. Some elements, such as nickel in pattern-welded stock, can make overheating more of a problem, so many smiths stay toward the lower end.
If you are working with an unfamiliar steel, test with scrap first.
Reading colour and surface
Colour changes with the light in your shop, so judge it in a consistent environment. In general:
- Medium orange is too cold for a reliable forge weld, even though the steel is plenty hot to forge.
- Bright yellow is the zone for most welds.
- Near-white, with a few sparks leaving the surface, is the edge of the range, particularly for higher-carbon steel.
- Heavy white sparks from the steel mean it is burning. Once that has happened, the steel is damaged.
The surface also helps. Flux should be runny and glassy, and the steel should look clean and bright through it.
Too cold versus too hot
Too cold is the more common beginner mistake: the weld looks joined but opens up on the next heat or when bent. Too hot burns the metal, leaving a rough, sparkling, crumbly surface that will not hold together.
Flux and heat
Flux lets the steel weld at a practical temperature by dissolving oxide and keeping new scale from forming. See why use borax when forge welding for details on how it works and how to handle it.
Practical tips
- Soak the work at heat so the core reaches the same temperature as the surface. A glowing surface on a cold core makes a poor weld.
- Many smiths weld, then lower the heat a little for the rest of the drawing out, to limit grain growth in higher-carbon steels.
- A forge that cannot reach welding heat is a common reason for failures. Check that your burners and airflow can support it; see our forge welding in a propane forge guide.
- Wear suitable eye protection for the glare at these temperatures.