Brazing, soldering and welding: the difference
All three methods join metal with heat, but they differ in what melts:
- Welding melts the edges of the base metal, so the two pieces fuse together, usually with added filler of a similar composition.
- Brazing uses a filler metal that melts above about 450°C (840°F) but below the melting point of the base metal. The base metal is heated but not melted.
- Soldering works the same way as brazing but with fillers that melt below that 450°C line. See soldering tools and materials for the kit involved.
Because the base metal stays solid, brazing and soldering suit situations where melting the parts would distort or damage them.
Torch brazing (capillary joints)
In classic brazing, the parts are fitted with a small, consistent gap. When the joint is hot enough, the molten filler is drawn into the gap by capillary action and, when it cools, forms a thin, strong bond. Copper plumbing and tubing joints, and many small assemblies, are made this way. The fit-up matters more than the amount of filler.
Bronze welding (braze welding)
Bronze welding, also called braze welding, uses a similar filler (traditionally a copper-zinc “brass” or “bronze” alloy) but not capillary action. The joint is prepared like a welding joint, with a bevel or a vee, and the filler is built up in the joint like a weld bead. The steel is heated to a dull red so the filler wets and “tins” the surface, but the steel itself is not melted.
It is done with an oxy-acetylene torch and a flux, and it is often used for repair work on cast iron and steel, where the lower heat reduces distortion and cracking risk compared to fusion welding. For the underlying torch process, see our overview of gas welding.
Why braze instead of solder?
Brazed joints are generally stronger and can tolerate higher service temperatures than soldered ones. Soldering is fine for electrical work, small plumbing joints and jobs where heat sensitivity is the main concern. If the joint carries load or sees heat, brazing is the usual step up. The trade-off is that brazing needs a hotter torch and more care with fit-up and flux.
Torch fuels: can you braze with propane?
Yes, for the right job. A propane torch (often with air) can braze small copper and brass parts with low-temperature, silver-bearing brazing alloys, particularly on thin sections. Heavier steel parts absorb heat quickly, and plain propane-air torches may struggle to bring them up to temperature. Oxy-acetylene, or oxygen with another fuel, is the usual choice for larger work and for bronze welding. See do you use propane gas for welding for more on how propane fits in.
Filler metals and flux
- Silver-bearing brazing alloys flow at lower temperatures and are common for copper, brass and small steel assemblies.
- Copper-zinc (brass or bronze) rods are the traditional choice for bronze welding steel and cast iron.
- Copper-phosphorus alloys are used on copper-to-copper joints, usually without flux, but are generally not recommended for steel or other ferrous metals.
Flux cleans the joint, prevents oxidation while heating, and helps the filler wet the surface. Match the flux to the filler and base metals, and follow the manufacturer’s instructions. Some fluxes give off fumes, so ventilate the work area.
Basic steps
- Clean the surfaces to bright metal, removing paint, rust and oil.
- Fit the parts with the correct gap or bevel.
- Apply flux.
- Heat the base metal broadly and evenly, rather than blasting the filler.
- When the metal reaches the right temperature, touch the filler to the joint, away from the flame, so the heated metal melts it.
- Let the joint cool without disturbing it, then remove flux residue.
Bronze welding and motorcycle frames
Bronze welding has a long history in frame building. Lugged steel bicycle and motorcycle frames were traditionally brazed, and some builders still fillet-braze to give smooth joints. Many motorcycle frames are made of steel tube, though some use aluminium or cast sections, and the right repair method depends on the material.
A frame is a safety-critical part. A repair that looks good can still weaken the metal around it, and the heat can affect the tubing’s strength. If you are thinking about repairing a motorcycle frame, have a qualified frame builder or certified welder assess the damage first. Cracks, bends and previous repairs are not a good place to experiment.
Limits
Brazed and bronze-welded joints are not as strong as a fusion weld of the same metal, and the filler can soften at high temperature. Parts that will be galvanised, painted or heated after brazing need thought, and the filler colour often does not match the base metal. For joining at much higher temperatures, a different process such as forge welding may be relevant.