Hardfacing vs reclamation welding
The two terms overlap, and they are often combined in one repair, but they describe different goals.
- Reclamation (buildup) welding restores a worn or damaged part to its original size and shape by depositing weld metal where material has been lost. The aim is dimensional recovery.
- Hardfacing (also called hard surfacing or wear overlay) deposits a wear-resistant alloy on a surface to resist abrasion, impact, heat or corrosion. The aim is a longer service life, whether on a new part or a repaired one.
A typical job on heavy equipment might build a worn edge back up with a tough, compatible alloy, then finish with a hard cap layer.
Common applications
- Earthmoving buckets, teeth, cutting edges and blades
- Agricultural tillage tools and plow parts
- Crusher and mining wear parts
- Shafts, rolls and other worn cylindrical parts (these may use automated processes)
- Rail and general maintenance repairs
Processes used
Several arc processes can do this work:
- Stick (SMAW). Hardfacing electrodes are widely available and suit field repair.
- Flux-cored and metal-cored wire. Tubular hardfacing wires run through a MIG-style wire feeder. This is what people usually mean by “hardfacing with a MIG welder.” Some wires are gas-shielded and others are self-shielded; see flux-cored vs MIG for how the two wire types differ.
- Submerged arc. For large, repetitive overlays and cylindrical parts, SAW offers high deposition rates.
- Oxy-fuel and other methods. Used for specific alloys and small work.
Ordinary solid MIG wire is used mainly for buildup with mild-steel-type deposits; most true hardfacing alloys are too heavily alloyed to draw as solid wire, which is why they come as tubular wire.
Choosing a hardfacing wire or rod
Match the consumable to the wear you actually have:
- Abrasion (sand, soil, rock sliding past): harder deposits, often with hard carbides, tend to last longer.
- Impact (hammering, shock): tougher, less hard alloys resist chipping and cracking better.
- Mixed abrasion and impact: typically a compromise alloy, or a tough base layer under a harder cap.
- Heat or corrosion: specialty alloys are made for these.
Manufacturers publish selection charts and datasheets that list recommended polarity, shielding gas, wire diameter, number of layers and preheat. Follow the datasheet for the specific product, since these vary widely between alloys.
Basic procedure
- Identify the base metal. Carbon content and alloying decide preheat and filler. Austenitic manganese steel, for example, is usually not preheated and is kept cool, since overheating it can embrittle it.
- Clean the surface. Remove dirt, oil, paint and cracked or fatigued metal. See preparing metal for welding.
- Preheat if required. Medium and high carbon or alloy steels often need preheat to slow cooling and reduce cracking. Follow the datasheet or procedure rather than a general number.
- Build up if needed. Use a tough, compatible buildup alloy to restore dimensions and act as a cushion.
- Apply the hardfacing layer. Keep heat input controlled to limit dilution, where base metal mixes into the deposit and softens it.
- Cool slowly. Avoid quenching hardfacing deposits. Let the part cool in still air or insulated, as the datasheet recommends.
Some very hard deposits develop small, regular cracks across the bead as they cool. This can be normal for those alloys, but cracks that run into the base metal are a problem.
Common problems
- Cracking or spalling: often from too-hard an alloy on a part that sees impact, too many layers, or too little preheat.
- Excessive dilution: deposit comes out softer than expected, usually from high heat input or low travel speed.
- Poor bond: from contaminated surfaces or too cold a start.
- Distortion: from heat; staggered or balanced welding helps.
Related questions
Can you use MIG welding for steel? Yes. MIG (formally GMAW) is among the most common processes for welding steel, using solid or tubular wire. See the overview of welding processes.
What is MIG welding called now? The formal name is gas metal arc welding (GMAW). “MIG” (metal inert gas) is still widely used in practice.
Can you reweld a bad weld? Often, yes. The defective weld is usually ground or gouged out completely, the joint is re-prepared, and it is welded again. On code or safety-critical work, repairs normally have to follow a qualified procedure and be inspected, so check the applicable requirements.