What visual inspection is and why it comes first
Visual inspection (VT) is the process of examining a weld with your eyes, usually helped by lighting, gauges and magnification, to judge whether it meets the requirements for the job. It is the oldest and most widely used weld inspection method. It is also usually the first one performed, because it is quick, cheap and needs very little equipment.
Visual inspection can only evaluate what is on the surface or what you can see into. It will not find a hidden internal flaw. But many problems show up on the surface, and a weld that fails visually usually does not need any further testing before it is repaired.
Visual inspection is not a one-time step at the end. Good practice is to inspect before welding, while welding, and after welding.
Before welding: what to check
A surprising number of weld defects can be traced back to the setup. Before the arc is struck, an inspector or welder will typically check:
- Welding procedure and welder qualification. Confirm there is a procedure for the job and that the welder is qualified for it. See what WPS, WPQ and PQR mean.
- Base material. Is it the right type and thickness, and free of laminations, heavy rust, mill scale, paint, oil or moisture in the weld zone?
- Joint preparation. Bevel angle, root opening, root face and joint fit-up should match the procedure.
- Alignment. Check that the parts are aligned and tack welds are sound, with no cracks in the tacks.
- Filler metal and consumables. The electrode, wire or rod should be the correct type and in good condition. Low-hydrogen electrodes in particular need to be stored as the manufacturer directs.
- Preheat, if required. Verify it with a suitable temperature-measuring device rather than guessing.
During welding
Inspection between passes can catch problems before they are buried under the next layer. Things to watch:
- Interpass cleaning: slag and spatter should be removed before the next pass.
- Interpass temperature, where the procedure limits it.
- Each pass for cracks, porosity, lack of fusion at the sidewalls or undercut that would be hard to correct later.
- Whether the welder is following the parameters and technique in the procedure.
On multi-pass welds, the root pass deserves special attention because it is hard or impossible to see once the joint is filled.
After welding: what to look for
Once the weld has cooled and been cleaned, look at the weld as a whole first, then at details. An overall check should cover:
- Size and profile. Is the weld the specified size and length? Is the bead face reasonably uniform and smoothly blended into the base metal?
- Reinforcement. Excessive build-up and a very convex bead can create stress concentrations at the toes. Underfill leaves the weld below the surface of the plate.
- Toe blending. The weld should flow into the base metal without sharp transitions.
Then look for specific surface discontinuities:
- Cracks. Generally the most serious finding. Cracks are rarely acceptable in codes. See why welds crack and the specific case of crater cracks.
- Undercut. A groove melted into the base metal at the edge of the weld. See undercut causes, limits and fixes.
- Overlap. Weld metal that has flowed over the base metal without fusing to it.
- Porosity. Gas pockets visible as small holes on the surface, individually or in clusters.
- Incomplete fusion or penetration where visible, for example gaps at the toe or at the root.
- Burn-through and excessive root penetration (sometimes called “icicles” or sugaring on the back side).
- Spatter and arc strikes. Spatter is usually cosmetic, but arc strikes outside the weld can create hard, crack-prone spots on some steels, so many codes restrict them.
- Misalignment. Offset between the two members.
- Surface slag or inclusions left behind.
Pipe welding specifics
Pipe adds some extra things to look at:
- Hi-lo (internal misalignment). The difference in height between the inside surfaces of two pipe ends at the joint. A hi-lo gauge is made for measuring this. See pipe fit-up for how alignment is set before welding.
- Root condition. Where the inside of the pipe is accessible, check root penetration, concavity, and burn-through. Where it isn’t, a borescope or camera may be used.
- Position changes. On welds done in fixed positions, the start and stop points, tie-ins between passes and the bottom (6 o’clock) area often show defects first.
- Cap appearance. The final cover pass should be consistent in width and reinforcement all the way around, with no undercut at the toes.
Many pipeline and process-piping codes spell out how each discontinuity is to be measured and judged, so the specific code for the job matters.
Tools of the trade
You don’t need much equipment to start:
- A good flashlight or inspection lamp and, for tight spots, an inspection mirror.
- A magnifying glass or loupe.
- A tape measure or steel rule.
- Fillet weld gauges for leg size and throat.
- A bridge cam gauge or similar for reinforcement, undercut depth, and misalignment.
- A hi-lo gauge for pipe.
- Temperature-indicating crayons or a contact pyrometer for preheat and interpass checks.
- A borescope for interior surfaces.
Acceptance criteria and the WPS
Whether a given indication is acceptable depends on the governing code or specification, for example a structural welding code, a pressure piping code or a pipeline standard. These differ in what they allow for undercut, porosity, reinforcement height and other features, and limits can differ again by service conditions such as cyclic loading. Always check the contract documents and the code that applies, rather than relying on a general rule of thumb.
The welding procedure specification sets the parameters the weld should be made with, and inspectors often compare what they see with it. The article on WPS, WPQ and PQR explains how those documents fit together.
Inspectors who work to a code typically need appropriate qualification. Certified Welding Inspector (CWI) is a widely recognized credential in North America, and other regions have their own schemes.
The basics that prevent visual defects
People sometimes ask about “the five basics of welding” (see the 5 essentials in welding). There isn’t one universal list, but versions of it commonly cover the same set of fundamentals: clean, well-fitted joints, correct machine settings for the material and thickness, correct electrode or torch angle, a consistent arc length or stick-out, and a steady travel speed. Nearly every visual defect above comes from getting one of these wrong. Undercut, for example, is often linked to excessive current or travel speed, and porosity to contamination or poor shielding.
When visual inspection isn’t enough
Visual inspection cannot see inside the weld. If the job requires confirming internal soundness, other non-destructive methods are used alongside it:
- Dye penetrant testing for surface-breaking flaws that are hard to see by eye.
- Magnetic particle testing for surface and near-surface flaws in ferromagnetic materials.
- Ultrasonic testing and radiographic testing for internal flaws.
Simple visual inspection checklist
- Confirm the procedure, materials and welder qualification.
- Check joint prep, fit-up and cleanliness.
- Verify preheat and interpass temperature where required.
- Inspect root and intermediate passes as work progresses.
- After cleaning, check size, profile and reinforcement.
- Look for cracks, undercut, overlap, porosity, incomplete fusion and arc strikes.
- Measure anything questionable with the right gauge and compare to the code.
- Record the results and decide: accept, repair, or send for further testing.