What a crater crack looks like
A crater crack is a crack that forms in the crater, the small depression left at the end of a weld bead when the arc stops. They are often called star cracks because several short cracks can radiate from the center of the crater in a star pattern. Sometimes there is only a single short crack, along the length of the crater or across it.
They are small, but they matter. A crack is a sharp flaw, and it can spread into the weld or the base metal under load or during later welding. Most codes do not accept cracks of any size.
Why crater cracks form
When you break the arc, the weld pool at the end of the bead freezes quickly. The crater is thin, because there isn’t enough filler metal to fill it, and it is the last metal to solidify. As it cools and shrinks, tensile stress builds in it. If the stress exceeds what the weak, partly solidified metal can take, it cracks.
Crater cracks are generally regarded as a form of solidification cracking (sometimes called hot cracking). This type of crack happens while the weld metal is solidifying or just after, when the last liquid is still present between grains and the metal has very little strength. The crater is a typical place for it because it is the last to freeze and its shape concentrates the shrinkage.
Factors that make crater cracking more likely include:
- Stopping the arc abruptly and leaving a deep, unfilled crater.
- Welding at high current or with a deep, narrow weld pool.
- Base or filler metals that are prone to solidification cracking, for example some aluminum alloys, or materials with high sulfur or phosphorus.
- Restrained joints, where the surrounding metal cannot move as the weld shrinks.
- Contamination of the joint.
Where they show up
Crater cracks can occur with any arc process when the arc is ended carelessly: stick, MIG, flux-cored and TIG. They are commonly mentioned in connection with aluminum and with some stainless steels, which are more crack-sensitive, but they can occur on carbon steel too. Fillet welds and weld ends on thin or restrained material are common places.
How to prevent them
The goal is to leave a crater that is full, rather than a deep hollow. Common techniques are:
- Fill the crater before stopping. Pause briefly at the end of the bead, or add a small amount of filler, so the crater is filled to roughly the level of the bead. The stick technique is shown in how to lay a weld bead.
- Taper off the heat gradually. In TIG welding this is usually done with a foot pedal or a torch-mounted control, or by slowly lengthening the arc while adding filler.
- Use the crater-fill (crater-fill/downslope) setting on a MIG or TIG machine if it has one, which reduces current at the end instead of stopping suddenly.
- Back-step or reverse direction. Moving back over the end of the bead for a short distance before breaking the arc can help fill the crater.
- Use run-off tabs. On welds where the end matters, the weld can run onto a tab that is removed afterward, leaving the crater outside the part.
- Reduce restraint and control heat. Good fit-up, sensible sequencing and not running excessive current all help.
- Use the right filler for the base metal. For crack-sensitive alloys, follow filler recommendations from the manufacturer or procedure.
- Keep the joint clean.
If you are looking at the broader picture of weld cracks, including those that don’t happen at the crater, see why welds crack.
How to find them
Large crater cracks can be seen with a flashlight and good eyes, but small ones can be easy to miss, especially under slag or in a rough crater. Check the end of every bead during visual inspection, with magnification if needed. Where cracks are suspected on a finished weld, dye penetrant testing is a common way to make fine surface-breaking cracks visible on non-magnetic materials, and magnetic particle testing may be used on ferromagnetic steels.
Repairing a cracked crater
Don’t just weld over a crater crack. The crack can remain in the weld and grow back through it. A typical approach is:
- Remove the crack completely by grinding or gouging until no crack remains.
- Confirm it is gone with penetrant or magnetic particle testing, where appropriate.
- Reweld, filling the crater properly this time.
- Re-inspect.
Repairs on code work normally need to follow the applicable procedure and may need to be documented.
Are crater cracks acceptable?
Most welding codes and specifications do not permit cracks of any size in a finished weld, and that includes crater cracks. Some specifications handle very minor crater defects differently, so the code for the job is the final word. In practice, it is easier and cheaper to prevent them with good arc-ending technique than to find and repair them later.