Short answer
Leaded solder is a tin-lead alloy. Lead-free solder replaces the lead with other metals, usually tin with small amounts of copper, silver, or others. The main practical differences are:
- Leaded solder melts at a lower temperature and tends to flow more easily, which many beginners find easier to use.
- Lead-free solder melts at a higher temperature and tends to look duller, but avoids lead and is required in many commercial products and applications.
Neither is “better” in every case. The right choice depends on what you are making, who will use it, and what rules apply.
Composition
Leaded solder is commonly a tin-lead mix such as 63/37 (63% tin, 37% lead) or 60/40 (60% tin, 40% lead). The 63/37 mix is a eutectic alloy, which means it melts and solidifies at a single temperature rather than passing through a slushy stage.
Lead-free solder is mostly tin. Common types include SAC alloys (tin-silver-copper), such as SAC305 (about 96.5% tin, 3% silver, 0.5% copper), and tin-copper alloys, which are generally cheaper. Some alloys add other metals to change how they flow or to improve strength.
Melting point and iron temperature
Eutectic 63/37 tin-lead solder melts at about 183°C (361°F). SAC305 and similar lead-free alloys melt at around 217–220°C. Some others melt higher.
In practice, that means a lead-free joint generally needs a hotter iron than a leaded one. A common pattern is to use an iron temperature several tens of degrees higher. The higher heat puts more stress on components and wears iron tips faster, so keep contact times short and look after your tips. Follow the solder manufacturer’s recommendations and the heat limits of the parts you are soldering.
How they work and look
- Leaded solder wets surfaces readily, flows smoothly, and typically produces bright, shiny joints. This makes bad joints easier to spot, since a dull joint stands out.
- Lead-free solder wets less readily and often gives a duller, more grainy finish, even when the joint is sound. That can make visual inspection less reliable. It can also be less forgiving with dirty surfaces or poor technique.
Lead-free joints are discussed in the electronics industry as being more susceptible to certain failure modes in demanding conditions, such as vibration or thermal cycling. For a hobbyist, these are rarely the main concern.
Safety
Lead is toxic. Exposure can build up over time, and children and pregnant people are generally considered more vulnerable, so these groups in particular should avoid contact with lead. This is general information rather than medical advice; consult official guidance or a doctor if you have concerns.
For hobby soldering with leaded solder, the main route of exposure is generally from lead getting onto hands and then into the mouth, not from breathing fumes at normal iron temperatures. Sensible precautions include:
- Wash your hands thoroughly after handling solder, and before eating, drinking, or touching your face.
- Do not eat, drink, or smoke at the bench.
- Keep solder, dross, and scraps away from children and pets, and dispose of them as hazardous waste where local rules require.
- Clean up solder dust and offcuts. Avoid dry sweeping or sanding that spreads dust.
Fume safety applies to both types. The smoke you see during soldering comes mostly from flux, and it can irritate eyes, nose, and lungs. Use a fume extractor or good ventilation whether the solder is leaded or not. Lead-free does not mean fume-free.
Regulations and where lead-free is required
- Drinking-water plumbing. In the US, lead solder is not allowed for potable water systems, and lead-free solder is standard for these joints. Other countries have similar rules. See how to solder copper pipe joints.
- Consumer electronics. The EU’s RoHS directive restricts lead in most electronics, and many manufacturers elsewhere follow it. Some specialized sectors have exemptions.
- Food-contact items and children’s products. Lead-free is the safe choice, and in many places the law requires it.
- Your own repairs. Rules for personal repairs and hobby work vary by place. Check local requirements.
Cost
Lead-free solder generally costs more, mainly because of the metals it contains, especially silver. Tin-copper alloys are a cheaper lead-free option. Leaded solder is usually cheaper, though in some places it is harder to buy.
Which to use
- Beginner electronics at home, for personal use: either works. Leaded solder is often easier to learn on, as long as you handle it carefully and follow the hygiene steps above. If you would rather avoid lead altogether, lead-free is fine with a temperature-controlled iron and good flux.
- Electronics you will sell or give to others, or repairs on modern equipment: lead-free is the safer default, and may be required.
- Drinking-water pipes: lead-free only.
- Food or drink containers and cookware: lead-free only, and use solder rated for the purpose.
- Jewelry and children’s items: avoid lead.
- Stained glass: traditionally uses tin-lead solder, but lead-free options exist. If the work is touched often or used by children, consider lead-free.
- Silver soldering and pewter: these use different alloys, so this choice does not apply. See silver soldering for jewelry and soldering pewter.
Mixing leaded and lead-free
Avoid mixing the two on a joint if you can. Combining them can produce a joint with a different melting behavior and, in some cases, poorer reliability. If you must rework a lead-free board with leaded solder, remove as much of the old solder as you can first. Keep leaded and lead-free solders clearly labeled and separate, and consider using separate tips or cleaning tips well between uses.
Tips for working with lead-free
- Use flux, and consider adding extra flux to the joint.
- Raise the iron temperature moderately, but do not exceed what the parts can take.
- Use a clean, well-tinned tip and a tip with enough thermal mass.
- Do not judge the joint on shine alone. Look at the shape: a smooth concave fillet that has wetted the whole pad and lead.
- If a joint goes wrong, the steps in how to fix a soldering mistake still apply.
For the rest of the kit you will need, see soldering tools and materials.